BJJ House Okinawa

A score doesn’t need a tournament

Competition has a defined shape. A clock, a referee, a points table published by a federation like the IBJJF, and an end. You enter it on a date, you prepare for it, and afterwards it’s over. It’s a good tool, and part of why it works is that it’s bounded.

A score doesn’t need any of that. Two people, a training round, one of them quietly keeping count. Nobody announced anything, there’s no medal, and the count is still enough to change what the round is for.

That version travels. It shows up in rooms where nobody competes, on ordinary Tuesday nights, between people who’d tell you honestly they have no interest in tournaments. The frame doesn’t require the event. It only requires a way of looking, and once it’s there it behaves the same way it does under a referee.

Every round has an objective

Whether you name it or not, a round has an objective, and the objective decides what happens inside it. Under a score the objective settles into something plain: don’t lose this one.

Nothing about that is shameful. It’s a normal thing to want. But follow what it does, because it does the same thing every time. If the objective is to not lose, then every decision inside the round gets measured against it. Entering a position where you’re clumsy costs you. Staying where you already function protects you. Neither of those arrives as a thought you have and weigh. It’s arithmetic, and it runs on its own.

Elsewhere on this site there’s an argument about what a scored round does to a single hour: it starts producing verdicts about you instead of information about the position. What follows here is the same mechanism running much longer. Do it three nights a week for six years and it isn’t a preference any more. It’s a curriculum.

The map stops growing

The hours pile up unevenly. Most of them land in the four or five positions where you already work, and almost none land where you don’t. So you get good. Genuinely good, inside a narrow band, and none of that skill is fake.

Meanwhile the map stops growing. The positions you never enter don’t become neutral just because you’ve been avoiding them. They’re where you’ll be the moment somebody puts you there, and outside a match nobody asks your permission first. That’s the part a scoreboard hides. In a competition you’re allowed to steer toward your strength. In a situation, the situation picks.

Competitive mentality inside training selects for the positions a practitioner already wins from, because those protect the score. Over years the hours concentrate there and the rest of the map stays empty. The result is a specialist who is genuinely strong inside a narrow band and stuck outside it, which is a different thing from being unskilled.

Better at scoring, and better at the art, are two directions

The two separate here, and it’s the whole point. A game that evolves under a score evolves toward the score. That’s what selection does. It doesn’t evolve toward covering what you can’t do, because covering what you can’t do costs points on the way there.

Sometimes the two directions overlap. A cleaner guard pass is a cleaner guard pass. But they overlap only when the thing that scores happens to also be the thing that fills a gap, and there’s no mechanism making that true. It’s a coincidence, and coincidences don’t accumulate reliably across ten years. What accumulates reliably is whatever the objective was.

This is also where the Flow Jiu Jitsu System puts its twelve connected blocks in the order it does: the order exists to build the map, rather than to sharpen the part of it you already like.

Underneath it: an answer, or a fundamental

There’s a second effect, quieter and slower than the first. Under a score, technique gets learned as an answer. This situation, that response, filed for retrieval. Answers are what a scored round rewards, because an answer produces a result now.

Kata works the other way round. The movement is there to deposit fundamentals: mobility, structure, the feel of a lever. Those turn up later, in situations nobody rehearsed. It isn’t a response waiting for its matching situation to appear.

So two people can drill the identical technique for a year and walk away holding different assets. One has a response, filed under the conditions it was learned in. The other has a principle that keeps generating responses in positions the drill never covered. The technique didn’t decide which of those got built. The objective of the room did. And the objective of a room is mostly set by the order things get taught in.

And that’s the honest account of a gap. A gap isn’t a missing move. It’s a situation you have no way of answering, because everything you own is an answer to some other situation.

The obvious objection

Let me be honest here: plenty of excellent practitioners are deep specialists, and it works for them. A game built around one guard and refined for a decade beats a broad, shallow game most nights of the week. Depth isn’t the problem.

The question is how the depth arrived. Depth chosen after the map was built is mastery. Depth that arrived because everything else quietly cost too much to enter is something else wearing the same clothes, and from the inside the two feel identical. Which is what makes it worth checking rather than assuming.

Most of us have one

Most of us have a position we haven’t been in for a year without ever having decided to avoid it. There was no moment. It just never got picked, round after round, and the not-picking was invisible each time it happened.

And most of us have had the other thing too. A roll where you were already losing, nothing left to protect, and something appeared that you’d never done before. Usually with a partner you weren’t worried about.

Two things sit underneath this one. Hours repeated without investigation deposit very little whether or not anyone is counting, and most rooms only ever run one of the three modes a round can run in.

Same mat, different objective

Which means the useful question isn’t about competing at all. Compete if you want to. It’s a good tool, it has a date on it, and a practitioner who trains this way and then competes arrives with more to compete with, not less.

The question is what tonight’s round is for. A round with nothing to protect can afford the position you’re bad at, and that position is the only place the map grows. It costs one round. The score you’d have protected wasn’t being recorded anywhere.

The free opening lesson of the system is built around this, before any technique: it’s here, and it costs nothing.

So: which position have you not been in for a year? And was that a decision, or an accumulation of nights when it wasn’t worth the points?


If you want the idea behind all of this in one sitting, Lesson Zero is free. Twenty minutes, filmed at the dojo in Ginowan. It’s the opening lesson of the Flow Jiu Jitsu System.

Watch Lesson Zero, free →

You’ll get the lesson by email, plus a short series on the ideas behind the system. Leave whenever you want.


Helio Damiani Jr. is a 5th-degree black belt and has been teaching jiu jitsu for 28 years, in Brazil and Japan. He founded BJJ House Okinawa in Ginowan, where he still teaches classes of no more than ten students. He is the author of Budo — The Path of Martial Arts and Flow Jiu Jitsu — Awakening the Inner Martial Artist. More about Helio →

I’m a jiu jitsu instructor, not a doctor or physiotherapist. Nothing here is medical advice — if something hurts, see a professional.

Student Login